This is the article rejected by Economic and Political Weekly. This was written in response to Professor Saibababa`s article. It was meant to be a corrective to many of the factual mistakes done by him. By rejecting it, and not publishing any other article correcting the factual mistakes of Prof. Saibababa, EPW has allowed his wrong assumptions to remain unquestioned. Of course, my blog does not have as many readers as EPW has. Still, I hope ideas don`t die.